|
An "IT Insider" Approach to Correcting
Profound Deficiencies
in IT Salary Surveys
Why IT salary surveys have big
problems...and how we fixed them.
Rapidly
evolving information technology jobs are so unique in the universe of business
employment that using passive surveying methods to obtain compensation benchmark
data now yields extremely inaccurate results. Why? Because of the massive
mismatch problem that now exists between IT job titles and what these
professionals actually do on-the-job.
The
“job title thing” is an epidemic widely acknowledged by HR compensation
professionals and IT salary surveyors alike.
It affects more than half of all employed IT workers by even the most
conservative estimates. Making the
situation worse is that the most reputable HR consulting firms, including Towers
Perrin, William M. Mercer, Watson Wyatt, Hewitt, and Aon/Radford, refuse to
offer a solution via their off-the-shelf IT salary surveys:
You must contract with them for expensive custom survey consulting.
Our
solution more than 15 years ago was to create a new methodology---dubbed “IT
Insider”---that produced the first salary surveys in North America to define
and benchmark “new breed" IT positions and job families in Data
Warehousing/Business Intelligence, Unix, NT, Web/I-net, e-Commerce, and Business
Technology (1994-1995) and IT Security, SAP and other enterprise
software applications (1997).
The
IT Insider method corrects for
job title/job content mismatches by reclassifying
surveyed participants according to what they do on-the-job and assigning to them
the most accurate job title before their pay data is loaded into our
survey data compilation engine. It
is time-consuming, expensive, and requires a deep grounding in technology and
the nuances of IT professional employment.
Along
with having that unique grounding, Foote Partners has unprecedented access to IT
workers at more than 1,980 research partner employers. Overall,
our methodology
produces better
data screening and cleaning, superior statistical reliability and validity, and constantly
refreshed and consistent ‘real world’ salary and tech skills pay data. No
other IT compensation survey research firm today publishes off-the-shelf surveys
that use IT job title alignment methods.
IT
infrastructure positions form a strong foundation for our research, however
Foote Partners’ competitive distinction has long been its focus on those
critical new strategic and tactical positions often unreported (or
under-reported) in other IT surveys. Findings are updated continuously and
published every three months, aided by our constant flow of confidential IT
compensation data from North American public and private sector employer HR
departments and IT, HR, and business executives research partners.
Our relationships with our research partners---many of whom
were clients, colleagues, and associates of our senior research team of former
McKinsey & Company, Towers Perrin, Gartner and META Group consultants and
analysts---have been forged over many years. We have access not only to their IT
compensation databases but to IT managers and workers to facilitate the
matching of job content with comparable job titles.
Foote
Partners surveys IT compensation job-by-job, city-by-city: 130 positions, 82
cities in the United State and Canada. There are no geographic multipliers used
in our research, no cost-of-living coefficients. Ours is constantly refreshed
‘real world’ salary and skills pay data.
What we do that others don't
Several aspects of Foote Partners’
compensation data collection methodology set us apart from other IT salary
survey firms.
 |
We are the only firm
in North America that corrects for job title/job content mismatches for
surveyed workers before the survey data
enters the data compilation phase.
All that is needed is for our research staff or our customers to
match their workers to our detailed, long form job descriptions that are
regularly updated to keep up with changing job conditions
|
 |
We survey and report
the market values of 424 popular IT skills and certifications, and as with
all Foote Partners pay surveys, we recompile and update continuously and
publish our surveys every three months.
So if you aren’t willing to re-title jobs to match actual content
but you need to differentiate workers within a broad job title (such as
"software programmer", “developer” or "systems
administrator"), you can use our skills pay survey data to add
at-risk pay or adjust base pay for the presence of various IT
skills. As such, you can benchmark workers’ pay to what their job titles
should be.
|
 |
We use no aggregated data sources
or compilation of others' surveys, instead collecting
our data from 2,000 research partner organizations job-by-job,
city-by-city, continuously throughout the year.
|
 |
Foote Partners’ uses
an experienced team of former Gartner and META Group industry analysts,
McKinsey & Company and Towers Perrin consultants, and former corporate
HR, IT, and business executives, who have unprecedented access to more
than 93,000 IT workers.
We work closely with thousands of public and private sector
research partner organizations to correct salary survey problems, which
just begins with the job title/job content discontinuities mentioned
above. Overall, our
innovative methods produce better data screening and cleansing, superior statistical
reliability and validity, and constantly
refreshed and consistent ‘real world’ salary and tech skills pay data.
|
 |
As
former senior analysts and consultants at top IT analyst and business
consulting firms we have an insider's knowledge of evolving technology,
HR, and business drivers and trends.
We keep a close watch on the movement of IT jobs in central IT
service centers but also in lines of business that bring IT workers in
continual contact with internal and external customers---the so-call
'hybrid' IT jobs that now define a rapidly emerging new breed of IT
worker. |
 |
We track
critical labor market fluctuations and have an insider's knowledge of
evolving technology. We keep
a close watch on the movement of IT jobs in lines of business that bring
IT workers in continual contact with customers---the so-call 'hybrid' IT
jobs that now define the new breed of IT worker.
|
 |
We can use our
research database to generate custom surveys and reports on a variety of
IT and business management trends and better/best practices, serving as
the foundation for our consulting practices.
|
IT salary and cash bonus pay
Survey results
from our quarterly IT
survey of more than 130 critical IT jobs are available in any combination for
up to 84 US and Canadian cities. Our
more than 1,600 salary and skills pay survey customers decide exactly what they need and how much to spend.
While
infrastructure positions form a strong foundation for our research, Foote
Partners’ competitive distinction has long been its focus on those critical
new strategic and tactical positions often unreported (or under-reported) in
IT surveys published by large firms such as Mercer, Watson Wyatt, Hewitt,
Aon/Radford, Towers Perrin, and others. Findings are updated and published
every three months
Long-form
JDs
accompany all orders so there’s no confusion.
For info on obtaining detailed long-form job descriptions see:
IT
certifications
and skills pay
Foote Partners' Quarterly
IT Skills & Certifications Pay Index and Salary/Bonus and Skills
Pay Combination Reports are the popular choices for hundreds of employers
seeking to differentiate pay for workers possessing various technical
certifications or skills. The market values of 424 IT skills and certifications are compiled and published every three
months, with data from North American and European employers.
Research
participant metrics
IT compensation data for our 2010 research findings were collected from 2,000 public and private sector organizations representing more than
40 private sector
industries plus government and educational institutions.
Approximately 93,000 IT workers are included in our continuously
updated surveys.
The size of
the participating organizations, measured most appropriately for the type of
business, by revenues, assets, total premiums and operating budgets, are as
follows:
--13%
of participating organizations have $3 billion+ in sales/$15+ billion in total
assets
--25%
of participating organizations earn more than $1 billion in annual revenues or
more than $3 billion in total
assets
--44%
of participating organizations have $500+ million in sales/$1+ billion in
total assets/$500+ million in premiums/$500+ million operating budget
(government, educational, not-for-profit)
--56%
of participating organizations fall in the SMB (small-to-medium sized
business) segment, generally defined as organization under $500 million in
sales.
--[Public
sector] 5% have operating budgets of $500 million or more,
[nonprofit/educational sectors] 4% with operating budgets $100 million to less
than $500million
How do we get such accurate data in so many cities?
It takes us approximately
eighteen months to fully survey a new city or labor market----to identify the key employers and
market players in a single city or labor market, and then collect sufficient
accurate information to be able to offer, on a quarterly basis, regularly
updated complete sets of salary
and skills data for all FP positions in that location. We will not release data
in any city until we have accurate representative data that have been verified and validated,
covering all IT positions in our general survey. Every year we release data for new
cities and new IT positions.
Survey
frequency and availability
We are the only source in
North America for continuous quarterly IT salary survey research. This has made Foote
Partners the popular choice for companies who know that while some IT positions
need annual surveying, others require more frequent comparisons to keep up with
volatile labor market segments.
Surveying during these months...
Produces research published...
|
1st Qtr
(January, February, March) |
April 10th |
|
2nd
Qtr
(April, May, June) |
July 10th |
|
3rd
Qtr
(July,
August, September) |
October
10th |
|
4th
Qtr
(October, November, December) |
January 15 (following year) |
|